» Patents

$166 Million Verdict Vaca…

$166 Million Verdict Vacated: The Perils of Confused Expert Testimony

The Federal Circuit has issued a decision reversing a district court’s denial of judgment as a matter of law regarding noninfringement of a radio-related patent. The court also vacated a significant damage award in favor of Finesse Wireless LLC. As… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Federal Circuit Upholds $…

Federal Circuit Upholds $3.5 Million Jury Award in Wallet Ninja Patent Lawsuit

The Federal Circuit has affirmed a $3.5 million district court jury award in favor of Dynamite Marketing, Inc. for infringement of its US Patent No. D751,877. As the court explained, In early 2013, Alexander Shlaferman (“Shlaferman”), the princip… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Federal Circuit Reverses…

Federal Circuit Reverses on Laches: Google Lacked Prejudice Proof

The Federal Circuit has reversed in part and affirmed in part a district court decision finding Sonos’s patent claims for controlling media playback systems invalid. The court reversed the district court’s decision that Google was prejudiced by S… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents, Technology
Federal Circuit Affirms P…

Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Board in First Derivation Proceeding Appeal

The Federal Circuit has affirmed the decision of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB or Board) in the first appeal of a derivation proceeding under the America Invents Act (AIA) litigated at the Board. The case is Global Health Solutions LLC v. S… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Obviousness Win: Federal…

Obviousness Win: Federal Circuit Affirms Glucose Sensor Claims Unpatentable

The Federal Circuit (CAFC) affirmed a Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB or Board) ruling that claims of DexCom, Inc.’s patent for implantable glucose sensors were unpatentable as obvious. As the court explained, This appeal involves implantable g… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Fourth Circuit Rules agai…

Fourth Circuit Rules against Sysco in Trade Secret Appeal

The Fourth Circuit has affirmed a ruling from a North Carolina district court dismissing trade secret claims, copyright claims, and other claims brought by the Taiwanese company Sysco against its American distributor. The case is Sysco Machinery Corp… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
The High Cost of Cancelin…

The High Cost of Canceling: How Prosecution History Estoppel Killed a Heart Valve Infringement Claim

The Federal Circuit has overturned a $125 million patent judgment against Medtronic’s CoreValve unit for allegedly infringing a Colibri Heart Valve LLC patent. The court found that Colibri’s arguments and amendments barred Colibri’s ass… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents

"Consisting Essentially Of": Federal Circuit Upholds Atypical Claim Meaning Based on Prosecution History

The Federal Circuit has vacated an obviousness ruling by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB or Board) that invalidated patent claims to methods of treating eye redness. The court found that the Board used an erroneous construction of the phrase… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Federal Circuit Reverses…

Federal Circuit Reverses Patent Board in X-Ray Magnification Case

The Federal Circuit reversed a Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB or Board) determination that Carl Zeiss failed to prove that patent claims to X-ray imaging systems incorporating projection magnification were invalid as anticipated by a scienti… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents
Federal Circuit: Check De…

Federal Circuit: Check Depositing Too Abstract for Patent

The Federal Circuit has reversed a summary judgment ruling from a district court, finding that patent claims directed to the idea of depositing a check using a handheld device are abstract and thus unpatentable. The case is United Services Automobile… Read More
Read More
Categories: Patents